DESCRIPTION
In this fiery episode I tackle one of the most misunderstood controversies in modern Catholic discourse: the Church’s recent directive discouraging the use of Co-Redemptrix as a title for Mary. Why did the Church say what it said? What actually changed — and what didn’t? And why are so many Catholics reacting with confusion, anger, or even defiance?
Follow me on X | Instagram | TikTok
My personal Newsletter, with rundowns of the week’s publications and podcasts, and exclusive commentary - CatholicFirebrand.com
What begins as a theological breakdown widens into an honest, hard-hitting exploration of obedience, humility, and the growing crisis of pride within the Catholic world. I share personal stories, insights from the battlefield of social media, commentary on schism-like attitudes, and a pastoral reflection on why following the Magisterium is so difficult for modern Catholics — and why Jesus Himself set the pattern.
Bold, candid, and full of practical clarity, this episode cuts through the noise and calls Catholics back to the difficult and liberating virtue of obedience.
SHOW NOTES
1. Co-Redemptrix: What the Church Actually Said
Distinction between titles and theological descriptors
Why the term Co-Redemptrix has never been a formal title
The Church’s reasoning: avoiding confusion, clarifying Mary’s unique but subordinate role
The theology stays intact; the terminology is what’s being discouraged
Why titles must be grounded in Scripture or Tradition
Benedict XVI’s statements on the lack of historical support
Why true cooperation does not imply equality with Christ
Co-Redemptrix
2. Why Some Catholics Are Angry
Breakdown of reactions on X vs. Substack
How online hostility revealed a deeper issue: a lack of obedience
Why sentiment and melodrama can’t trump theology
Examples of poor theological reasoning used to “refute” the Magisterium
The irony of people “defending Mary” against the Church her Son established
Co-Redemptrix
3. Obedience in Catholic Life
Obedience is not optional—it’s a foundational Christian virtue
Why following Jesus was also difficult for His first disciples
The Church as the mystical Body of Christ: to follow Christ means following Her
Why “What if the Church is wrong?” is the wrong question
Distinction between incomplete vs. erroneous teaching
The Holy Spirit guiding the Church through today’s “desert” moment
Why Catholics must resist the urge to self-appoint as watchdogs or crusaders
Co-Redemptrix
4. The Modern Crisis of Pride
Catholics refusing correction even when documents are presented
The danger of clinging to error out of pride
The temptation to treat personal opinion as equal to Magisterial teaching
“Soft schism” within the Church — TLM vs. Novus Ordo identity wars
Why division is rooted in pride, not doctrine
Co-Redemptrix
5. A Pastoral Case Study: Confirming Someone in an Irregular Relationship
Why sacramental theology sometimes surprises people
Why living in sin doesn’t automatically disqualify someone from confirmation
The Church’s responsibility to hope rather than assume the worst
Why such ceremonies should avoid scandal by being handled privately
The real difference between doctrinal discipline and pastoral prudence
Co-Redemptrix
6. The Cost of Evangelizing Publicly
Candid reflection on losing peace and tranquility for the sake of evangelization
Spiritual vulnerability that comes with speaking publicly for the faith
Why not every Catholic is called to be a public defender of the Church
Your primary mission is your own salvation—and the salvation of your family
Co-Redemptrix
7. Final Encouragements & Resources
Following the Church, even when it’s uncomfortable
The necessity of humility and docility for authentic discipleship
Invitation to go deeper via Catholic Firebrand & Stoking the Embers
The Rosary as a source of peace and clarity
EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS
“Co-Redemptrix has never been a title — it’s a theological descriptor, and the Church is simply preventing confusion.”
“The Church has not downgraded Mary. Nothing in the theology has changed at all.”
“Some Catholics are defending Mary from the Church — that’s the madness of today’s climate.”
“Obedience is part of the game. If you’re Catholic, this isn’t optional.”
“The problem isn’t just disobedience — it’s pride. Catholics who refuse correction cling to error because it’s theiridea.”
“When the Magisterium teaches, it is never wrong. Sometimes incomplete, but never wrong.”
“The Holy Spirit is leading the Church through a desert. Our job is to follow — not to complain about the sand.”
“Not everyone is called to be a warrior online. The Church doesn’t need you to defend her — she has the Holy Spirit.”
“Public evangelization costs your peace. Don’t take up that cross unless God asks you to.”
“Your mission is salvation — yours and your family’s. Everything else is secondary.”
Follow me on X | Instagram | TikTok
My personal Newsletter, with rundowns of the week’s publications and podcasts, and exclusive commentary - CatholicFirebrand.com
